We woke up in Sevierville and walked over to a pancake breakfast place. It was indicative of this area of Tennessee: the entire approach to Great Smoky Mountains National Park is lined with tourist-themed businesses, motels and restaurants and putt-putt golf places, in a profusion that I could hardly believe. Many people complain of the crowdedness of the National Parks, and if that is true anywhere, it is true here: more than nine million people visit the park each year, more than double the amount who visit any other national park. The area was crowded on a weekday morning in April: I can only imagine what it gets like during the summer. Much of the development, which was entirely car-driven (remember, we had tried to eat downtown the previous night, and found not a single option open at 8 p.m.), was big chain restaurants and hotels: you know the familiar signs by the roadside, Holiday Inn and Motel 6 and Wendy’s and Chili’s and all the rest (literally, all the rest). But a lot of places were local: this pancake house was not a chain, and it was made to look like a log cabin. Inside there was also a knick-knack shop, selling those souvenir license plates for people with names like “Jayden” and “Dylan” and “Dillon” and “Madison,” as well as teddy bears and keychains and wall hangings that said things like “Bringing your husband shopping is like going hunting with the game warden.”
Dollywood is nearby, along this same stretch, which is the same phenomenon of a locally owned tourist development.
I admire local business, and I also kind of like how useless and dumb tourist shops are, but that will not change the fact that the worst thing about visiting the Smokies is having to run this gauntlet of stop-and-go tourist-drivel sprawl. An hour of driving in such conditions exhausts me; and we would end up spending all day in it. It is worth detouring to avoid this approach.
Back from breakfast, I spoke with the owner of our hotel, who said that yes her husband was a good mechanic, but he was working on a project on a deadline. His brother, though, ran a repair shop and was very good. “He’s a good man,” she said. “He’s honest. And I’m not just sayin’ that.”
And I believed her. She called to see if they could look at the truck immediately, and they said yes. I thanked her and off we went.
The place was Rick’s Repair Shop, like everything else just down the six-lane highway. The man at the counter had a blond mullet which looked like it had suffered no substantial modification – with the exception of a few gray hairs – since 1981 when his dream girl had told him that she thought Daryl Hall was really hot. (See the Hall and Oates “Method of Modern Love” video to see what I’m talking about, and just for fun sing “M-U-L-L-E-T-O-F-L-O-V-E.”) He said they were expecting us, but they would need to take out the transmission just to take a look, so this was going to take time. In fact, it would take just about all day.
They said maybe they could speak with the transmission place in Lexington, and payment could be arranged. I said I’d call myself.
When I reintroduced myself to Troy, he said, “Ah knew you’d be callin’ us this mornin. Ah jes knew it. When I got back home las’ nigh, I said to mahself, ‘Ah nayver shoulda let him lave with that vee-hickle. That thing shoulda been bled a lot mawur.”
“Well, all I know is that it ain’t fixed. I’m in Sevierville.”
“Ah got a guy in Pigeon Forge, maybe you can talk to him.”
“I’m already at a place here. I’ll have them talk to you when I know the cost.”

This was the botanizing I did. There was an erigeron blooming in the parking lot. This photo, by the way, does not want to be rotated for some reason.
Meanwhile, we were still trying to get into the mountains. We discussed our options. I knew that just above us, in those mountains, was one of the paradises of the world, a wonderland of God’s beauties, and delay had made desire turn to madness. We decided to rent a car. Catherine got online and found some amazing $12 a day deal for a car. I will never understand the internet, and how just a few clicks online – if they are the right clicks, of course – can cut costs on a project by seventy or eighty percent. I thought $50 a day for a car would have been a good price.
The car company said they would come pick us up. So we waited and chatted with the people. A woman told us how amazing this place was – “You came to the right place. They’re very honest.” An older man told us that he had been instrumental in establishing the first “Church of the Nazarene” in town.
“Do you know that church?”
“No. What’s different about the Church of the Nazarene as opposed to other churches?”
I was looking for doctrine, but he said, “Well, in 1907 Joseph So-and-so started a church, and he got Phineas So-and-so to collaborate with him, and they started in Texas, and then they spread to such-and-such a place, etc.” And perhaps this was actually the relevant information. I always looked for the ideas, but maybe it was mostly about the people.
“We always have some back-and-forths, you know, certain things, with the Baptists. Now you know the Baptists are named after John the Baptist.”
“Yes.”
“Well: I always say: ‘Your church is named after John the Baptist. Ours is named after his first cousin.’” And he gave me a sly look to see if I understood, which of course I did.
“I think you got the right cousin.”
Conversation stalled there, and he said, “But these guys here, they’re very good. Very fair. Once my car had…”
And as this tale was being told, of all the good work they had done, who walked in but Keith Langdon, national park biologist who has done extensive work on the All Taxa Biodiversity Inventory, which has been attempting to discover and catalog every living species in Great Smoky Mountain National Park. In fourteen years of work, they have doubled the number of species known to be in the park, from from 9,511 to 17,527.
Now I did not know this gentleman by name, but I knew he was a naturalist as soon as he walked in: tall, with a baseball cap, a gray beard, tan cargo shorts and a tan button-down shirt that made him look ready for safari, and he had an old hiker’s physique: there was a tummy but the legs and glutes thin, strong, and well-used.
“Here for the wildflower pilgrimage?”
He looked at me as if he were surprised that someone could have been able to tell such a thing about him. Whereupon a conversation started and he gave me all kinds of useful information about the best places to see flowers in bloom right now. He rattled off species I had only the vaguest idea of – did I want to go see Phacelias or not? I wasn’t sure. He strongly recommended hiking down to White Oak Sinks. “And you may not see it, but there’s a Claytonia there with threadlike leaves, it’s very unusual.”
He was just there to drop his car off for an oil change. He lived in the area. “You came to the right place, I’ll tell you that. These guys… real honest.”
When he left I marveled at the coincidence. He was probably the single person in the whole area I most would have wanted to meet. And he had walked into a service station I never in a million years would have wanted to be stuck in. About an hour later he returned to pick up his car again. “You still here?” Our car-rental pick-up had been delayed. I asked him if he could take us himself, when – of course, my phone rang. They were here to pick us up. Keith took my email and said he’d send me some more hike ideas.
“Good luck,” he said. “Remember, White Oak Sinks.”
So we loaded up all our stuff into the rental car. We were considering leaving the truck here; we would rent the car, drive to Louisiana, then Catherine would drive back, drop off the rental car, pick up the truck, and head back to Kentucky. But it was Good Friday now; Sunday, when she would be returning, was Easter; everything would be closed; they didn’t allow cars to be dropped off. It all just seemed impossibly difficult. Really, we needed that truck.
The gentleman who picked us up from the car rental place was very nice, well-attired in pressed pants and an expensive shirt. Traffic was bad getting from place to place in town, so it took awhile to get to the rental agency, and then we spent another fifteen minutes or so at the counter as our data was punched into a computer – it amazes me how long all that takes – and at long last we had a car. It was on empty, of course, so before heading out of town we filled up the gas tank.
Just as we pulled out we got a call: the truck was fixed and ready to go.
So we doubled back to the mechanic’s, and were told that the problem was human error: the engine had been shaved down a bit to get the new clutch in, but there was some kind of pressure on it, which left a gap and hence the gears couldn’t quite mesh. I didn’t really understand that part, but I understood the next: “No charge.” I tried to pay, but when refused I thanked them profusely and left a tip for the person who had done the work.
There was only one problem. “Where’s the key?” I asked.
“It’s not on the clipboard?”
“No.”
“Hmm. Must have fallen off.”

Looking for the key under the hood.
He came back a few minutes later, a bit flustered. No key. The key had vanished. We went out to the truck. It wasn’t there. We opened up the trunk to see if it was under the hood. Nothing. We checked on top of the dashboard. Nope. I cleaned out the floor of the truck – no go. The whole place got into the search. Normally I don’t even need a key, but they had put the ignition onto “lock” and from there the key was absolutely necessary.
I couldn’t believe it. I laughed, but it was a desperate kind of laughter. I just couldn’t get any of this right. I just could not get into the mountains, no matter what I did.
After watching them all scurry around staring at the ground and looking under things, I put my hand into my pocket and pulled out the key. Both I and the mechanic had apparently forgotten that he had given it to me. I felt like an idiot. The whole place had been turned upside down in the past half-hour: the whole business had been embarrassed by what appeared to be their own incompetence, when in fact the incompetence had all been mine. When I sheepishly told everyone – and to be honest, I think I would have rather just crawled under the earth than tell them – they just laughed. “Well, we can’t fahnd the key if it’s in your pocket!”
Catherine asked if I knew the way to the rental car place. I said of course and off we went. Whereupon I got completely lost, leading us on a wild goose chase through the stoplights of exurbia. We finally got back to the rental agency, where we had to go through the standing at the computer all over again as all the computerwork got filled out. By the time that was done and we had retransferred all our stuff, we were starved, and so we ate a very late lunch in another non-chain restaurant in the middle of a parking lot by the highway. It was late afternoon – a drizzly late afternoon, foggy and gray just as the name of the mountain range would suggest – before we finally got to the Smokies. It had taken three and a half days. But once I got there, all the misery would vanish from my thoughts. In fact, it was the beginning of an amazing series of peak experiences, from the Smokies down to the Gulf.
In the Footsteps of Clay.
28-Apr-14“Salways trouble with these Foward Rangers. It takes forayver to blade ‘em out. Say, whayn you chenge a clutch you gotta blade ‘em, to get the bubbles out, and it’s just takin’ forever to blade.”
Now I had no idea what he was talking about, but he had mentioned this “bleeding,” before, and I wasn’t going to ask about it now. I just wanted it done. He said lunchtime.
So we had another morning in Lexington. I knew that Catherine had passed by, but never visited, the Henry Clay estate, known as Ashland. Visits from friends are the time when we get things like this done. So we headed over to Ashland and made it for the ten o’clock tour.
Henry Clay was introduced by the guide as “the greatest president America never had.” He had run for president five times, twice receiving his party’s nomination, and never been elected. Lincoln apparently admired him, and called him his “beau ideal of a statesman.” It was a pattern: apparently most of his fellow-politicians thought highly of him. He was elected Speaker of the House on the first day of his first term in the House, which has not happened since.
He was probably unusually well placed for a politician: in the midst of westward expansion, Kentucky was neither settled tidewater nor pioneer territory: it was in the middle. It was the northernmost of the Southern states, but also the southernmost of the states which did not secede. It had steam traffic and commerce along the Ohio river, but also much inland countryside.
Henry Clay's dairy. Underground spaces used intelligently can replace refrigeration.
Clay seems to have had this middling quality in himself – had so much of it that he was extraordinary, in fact, and that was the general impression I got. He opposed slavery, but did hold title to sixty or so human beings himself (like Washington he freed them in his will). He opposed a national bank, but after having paid an electoral price for this position, he then supported one. He supported tariffs, but was involved in important legislation to gradually reduce them to placate the South Carolinians. He was a major – one might say primary – figure in the compromises of 1820 and 1850, which helped prevent a civil war between the states. It came anyway, of course: it just came later.
I don’t particularly think “he delayed the Civil War” is any greater an accomplishment than “he delayed the Revolutionary War” would be. But it is always possible that Clay’s delay is what allowed the North to win: with each year military technology at that time grew (in the North) more and more powerful. This technology – artillery, machine guns, superior ships, railroads – may have been necessary for the North to actually subjugate the South, which I believe was a desirable outcome.
It is hard to read more than a few paragraphs of Lincoln’s eulogy on Clay: it feels very distinctly like hot air. There are expostulations and grandiose statements, and not too many simple facts. In the end, whatever impression the person of Clay made on Lincoln, his legacy does not make much of an impression today. Stories I heard on the tour made him sound frivolous: gambling tens of thousands of dollars over cards, paying vast sums of money for fine racehorses, being a known womanizer. But such qualities might have made him dashing as opposed to frivolous, I suppose; at the very least they could have made him more vital. I do not deny that the prevention of war is a great virtue – and it has been claimed that Clay’s peacemaking virtue was so great, no civil war could occur while he lived. And his gambling and drinking and womanizing probably indicate a sociable and pleasant nature – and the ability to enjoy life is a virtue too. He built a fine house, and was a fine farmer: he was an expert on the production of hemp, his main cash crop. He commanded the respect and friendship of his peers.
But when compared with the political thought of his contemporaries the Abolitionists, Clay seems pallid and merely social. The vast majority of men are thralls of fashion, and lumps of clay in the mold of conformity: after decades, when the mold is removed and the clay stands on its own, the ridiculousness of the shape stands out. Clay was political and social; those were his horizons. In this respect, he stands against the best part of the American tradition. The ultimate teaching of the idea of limited government is that there are many questions – the greatest, in fact – which are outside the adjudication of any body of men. Such cases may appear before the courts, but they judge the courts in the end, the courts do not judge them. The South has since claimed that it was fighting for “States’ Rights,” and to some extent this is true: they fought for the State’s right, with a few speeches and a vote by parliamentary procedure, to strip any man they wished of his humanity. And the North fought for the principle of limited government: that in the end, no government had any right even to bring such a question before it; that governments were good sometimes for the questions they did not allow to be raised. I let Thoreau speak:
When Thoreau swings, it is hard not to feel that he lands his punches on the body of Clay:
Clay’s house was nice, though it was completely rebuilt after his death. The rebuilding effort, finished in 1857, was superb. Beams were large, furniture large, and everything looking to solidity and endurance, rather than cheapness and style. It also felt, as the entire latter half of the nineteenth century does in its architecture, rather masculine: there was a billiards room, and a study, and a library, and all of them looked like places where men drank whiskey and smoked cigars among dark panels and gothic detailing. But Thoreau’s words also can be applied to the house:
I'm sure Thoreau would have thought the Claytonia the best part of the house.
The answer, of course, is no, not entirely. The grounds were not part of the tour, but we spent some time walking around. The plantation once consisted of some 600 acres, but it was near town and it had almost all been subdivided into nice homes and sold off. There were no formal gardens of any note, though the lawns were entirely covered in Claytonia, spring beauty. Claytonia is a common spring ephemeral, but this profusion of it exceeded anything I had ever seen before, and it made one of the finest lawns I had ever seen. This was probably an indication that the lawn had been a lawn for more than one, and probably at least two, hundred years. The spring beauty had gotten in when the lawn was surrounded by wild land; and had not been subjected to the modern regimen of broadleaf herbicides. But the lawn had been kept short in all that time, because Claytonia cannot compete against taller plants; and it had expanded to take over literally acres of lawn. It was beautiful.
Catherine had an appointment, and so we zipped back home after our brief spin through the grounds. I went over to the transmission place – I was doing the annoying New Yorker thing again, but the parable tells us that importunity, and harassing, works even on the Gods – just to show my face. The truck was not ready. I ate lunch and stewed. I didn’t know if I was going to get this truck back, or if it was going to run ever again.
Perhaps it was having just heard all the gambling stories about Henry Clay; perhaps it was the fact that Lexington has streets named after celebrated racehorses; perhaps it was the story of Jack Kerouac going to the races at Gretna, having a vision about a horse, not betting on it, and watching it win and pay fifty to one (a story which sums up much of the problem of Kerouac); maybe it was just that I had been to the races the last time I had been in Lexington, with my high school debate team. But we were still stuck in Lexington, and we had done most of what there was to do there; so I decided that we should head for the racetrack. Maybe we’d make back some of the money we had lost on the truck.
And then I got a call. The truck was ready. Catherine packed her things, and I biked on down to the transmission place to get the truck. We were finally going to go.